Need appliance parts? Call 877-803-7957 now or use the parts search box:

Parts Search

Learn appliance repair at online the Master Samurai Tech Academy.  Learn more.  Earn more.

FAQs | Repair Videos | Academy | Newsletter | Podcast | Contact

Samurai Appliance Repair Man's Blog

  • entries
    760
  • comments
    812
  • views
    2,374,531

Soot: A Clear and Present Danger in your Gas Oven

Samurai Appliance Repair Man

4,067 views

I was at a service call on gas range the other day for an oven that wouldn't bake or broil. The cause turned out to be a bad range control board. Nothing unusual about that. The astonishing thing with this range was the inside of the oven cell-- all the surfaces inside were coated with a thick layer of soot (click the images for a larger view):

med_gallery_4_9_267282.png

med_gallery_4_9_3204623.png

This is NOT a normal condition in any gas range. If you see soot accumulated on your oven cell walls, even a little, STOP USING IT AND GET IT CHECKED OUT!

Soot is a product of incomplete combustion. So is Carbon Monoxide (CO), dubbed "the silent killer" because it is odorless and kills by displacing oxygen in your blood, making you sleepy and, in high enough concentrations, can make you take that final dirt nap. We've all heard the stories of people dying in their homes from CO poisoning. Improperly adjusted gas appliances, like the oven shown in the photos above, is one of the more common ways this happens.

A standard practice in the appliance industry is that all gas appliances, ranges, ovens, dryers, etc., come ready to burn natural gas. If you're going to use propane (also abbreviated LP for "liquid propane"), you have to convert the gas system in the appliance to safely burn it without producing soot or unsafe levels of CO.

Since propane burns hotter than natural gas (2,500 Btu/cu ft for propane vs. 1,030 Btu/cu ft for natural gas), it needs more air to make a "complete" (or at least safe and soot-free) combustion. If the air-fuel ratio (AFR) is too low (too much fuel or "too rich" in automobile terms), you'll create soot and unsafe levels of CO. If you're interested in some numbers on the AFR for natural gas and propane, start here.

While no combustion is 100% complete, you can still get close enough to prevent soot formation and keep CO production to safe levels.

The range in this service call is a Kenmore (Frigidaire-built) range that was purchased from a famous, nationwide retail chain (I'll give you one guess; hint: it's a Kenmore). This range, like all gas appliances, came ready to burn natural gas and needed to be converted for use with propane.

The customer paid the retailer for the conversion but it wasn't done properly. They converted the gas burners on the cooktop correctly by replacing the gas metering spuds for each burner with the smaller diameter spuds sized for propane. But they completely neglected to convert either of the gas burners in the oven (bake and broil). Behold (click the images for a larger view):

med_gallery_4_9_737427.png

med_gallery_4_9_1606327.png

To make matters even worse, when the customer called the retailer's customer service department to complain about the soot in the oven, they advised her to run the self clean feature which successfully produced copious amounts of soot and, at the 900F temperatures reached in the oven cell during self clean, baked the soot onto the oven walls. The soot will never come out. This range is only three years old and the oven is effectively ruined.

So how is the strange and mysterious conversion process done in gas ranges? It's really not a mystical experience at all. It's as simple as following the instructions and installing a few pieces that all manufacturers provide for this very purpose. For example, here is an official conversion instruction sheet that Frigidaire includes with the conversion kits for its ranges. GE's conversion instruction sheet has similar information but I think it's a little more comprehensive and easy-to-follow (you'll need to be an Appliantology Apprentice to download it).




2 Comments


DurhamAppliance

Posted

Excellent info as always.

Share this comment


Link to comment
Samurai Appliance Repair Man

Posted

Domo, Brother Durham.  

Share this comment


Link to comment
Samurai on Facebook - become a fan today! SamuraiRepairman on Google+ Check out our YouTube channel for lots of appliance repair tips and help! FixitnowSamurai on Twitter
 

  • Blog Entries

  • Blog Comments

    • Samurai Appliance Repair Man
      Lab Night 3, High voltage machine
      Cool rig!  As for the difference in current draw between the probe the ladder, you were seeing the extra current draw in the ladder as the arc! The stepped up voltage created enough potential difference for the electrons to actually jump that gap (with a starter nudge from the probe). Once the probe introduced an arc, the arc itself established a current path for the electrons to jump the two legs of the ladder and they could keep flowing back and forth as the arc travelled up the ladder.   
    • Lighthouse
    • Samurai Appliance Repair Man
      Whirlpool Drain (or if Prince was an Appliantologist)
      An opus magnum Appliantological send-off for one of rock's magic-hands superstars! Fantastic, Brother Durham! 
    • DurhamAppliance
      Applyricology, Best of Durham Music Vol 1
      so Everybodys posting with the Samurai Everybody here is out of sight We dont bark and we dont bite We keep things loose, we keep things lite so Everybody's posting with the Samurai Posting with the Samurai Appliantology makes us smart and bright It's such a fine and useful site so Everybody's posting with the Samurai We like our fun and we never fight you cant post here and stay uptight Your stove won't heat? Check out this site so everybody's posting with the Samurai Posting with the Samurai Appliantology makes us smart and bright Your washer's broke? We'll make it right So Everybody's posting with the Samurai [time to pull out that air guitar and solo!] Everybody here is out of sight We dont bark and we dont bite Fridge too warm? So log on tonight where Everybody's posting with the Samurai Posting with the Samurai Appliantology makes us smart and bright It's such a fine and useful site so Everybody's posting with the Samurai [repeat last verse a few times, ad lib, moan a bit then fade]           We all want to grow our companies,  but finding and keeping either qualified techs or finding anyone that posseses even the slightest work ethic is a difficult,  near impossible task.  This song laments this sad state of affairs but also is a tribute to the recent passing of one of the greats.  Whirlpool Drain (or if Prince was an Appliantologist looking for good help)  Maybe you never meant to cause me any sorrow
      Maybe you never meant to cause me any pain
      I only wanted to one time see you working
      I only wanted to see you
      working on a Whirlpool Drain Whirlpool Drain, Whirlpool Drain
      Whirlpool Drain, Whirlpool Drain
      Whirlpool Drain, Whirlpool Drain 
      I only wanted to see you
      Steaming up a Whirlpool Drain  I never wanted to be a hard-assed employer
      But neither could I be some kind of friend
      Now please go away,  go work for another
      For your employment with me has end Whirlpool Drain, Whirlpool Drain
      Whirlpool Drain, Whirlpool Drain
      Whirlpool Drain, Whirlpool Drain
      I only wanted to see you
      Underneath a Whirlpool Drain Dude, I know, I know
      I know  appliances are changing
      It's time we all reach out
      to learn something new, that means you too You say you want me to teach you
      But you can't seem to make up your mind
      So I think you better pack it
      Since you can't even Ptrap a Whirlpool Drain Whirlpool Drain, Whirlpool Drain
      Whirlpool Drain, Whirlpool Drain
      Service Owners, if know what I'm singing about up here
      C'mon, raise your hand Whirlpool Drain, Whirlpool Drain
      I only want to have one
      Only want to see one
      Working on a Whirlpool Drain      
      How Deep is Your Lint? or Dyer Fire ie Bee Gees as Appliantologists

      I believe that you
      Don't want your doors to be charcoal
      Or see the light from a fire in the darkest hour
      Nor want your house to fall
      And you may not think we care for you
      When you know down inside
      That we really do

      Then it's time for you to show
      How deep is your lint
      How deep is your lint
      You really need to know
      Because your dryer is a major tool
      That'll burn your house down
      When it should always be lint free
      If you love your family.

      How deep is your lint?
       
    • DurhamAppliance
      Customer Show and tell Video: Ice on Bottom of Freezer and Water on Floor
      Somebody has to keep an eye on you.  lol