Need appliance parts? Call 877-803-7957 now or use the parts search box:

Parts Search

Learn how to troubleshoot like a Master Samurai Tech...

Click here to check out our structured, online appliance repair training courses for rookies and experienced techs.

FAQs | Repair Videos | Academy | Newsletter | Podcast | Contact

Stay connected with us...

Samurai on Facebook - become a fan today! Sign up for our free newsletter and keep up with all things Appliantology. Subscribe to our YouTube channel for lots of appliance repair tips and help! Follow the Samurai on Twitter and get timely morsels of Appliantological Wisdom! Subscribe to our MST Radio podcast to learn secrets of the trade.
az_repair_gal

Whirlpool LA9200W Washer On Last Legs - Seeking Replacement Advice

25 posts in this topic

Hi all! With the help of this forum, I've managed to keep my Whirlpool LA9200W washer and LE9200H dryer operational for more than 21 years. I've taken apart and reassembled the washer multiple times and replaced just about every part in the pair over the years. it's been an incredible journey.

Now the dogs have worn out in the agitator for the third time, the cabinet shakes, and there is advanced cabinet rust around the bleach dispenser. I'm finally, reluctantly, ready to call it quits on this pair.

However, I'm uncertain where to go from here. So much has changed in the past 2 decades! I am not a fan of front-loaders for various reasons, so I'm only looking at top-loading. Yesterday I saw the Samsung WA5451ANW / DV5451AEW. The pair is recommended by Consumer Reports and the washer gets good consumer reviews (although some folks are disgruntled about low water levels and not being able to change settings once a cycle starts).

I believe the washer is direct drive, but there is no agitator. The pair has only been on the market since 2011, so you should not have come across them for repairs yet. So I would appreciate some general feedback about Samsung in general. (There's a very similar LG pair but I've always heard LG has quality control issues - is that still true?)

So... for the masters that have helped me over the years, here are my questions:

--What do you think of this Samsung pair? ($999/ea retail, my cost is $850 ea + tax, delivery etc.)

--If money were no object, what toploading duo would you buy for your own use?

--Considering my experience with the Whirlpool pair, do you think I will be able to repair these Samsungs after they fall out of warranty?

--Given ease/difficulty of repair, would you recommend I purchase an extended warranty?

Thanks!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Need appliance parts? Call 877-803-7957 now!

Thanks for the link, RegUS - so you think I'm better off sticking with something simple, something I know? I have to admit I was wowed by the new machines - 4.7 cu. ft, stainless tub, no agitator, etc. I figured I would have to deal with electronics no matter what I bought, but the machines in your link looks a lot like what I have now...

My biggest concern is that I won't have the skill to repair the Samsungs. That would be a big letdown after doing it myself for the last 2 decades.

Not to mention the price difference. Huh. This is definitely something to think about.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

PLEASE do not buy the Samsungs. If you are in over your head one of the only companies that will work on them is the service department of Best Buy.

Samsung is a Korean company. Whirlpool is an American company and most of their products are still assembled in the USA. If you MUST buy a front load washer, buy Whirlpools. At least Whirlpool's parts are readily available everywhere and everyone works on them. Samsungs parts are hard to get and lots of servicers refuse to work on them.

Edited by Scottthewolf

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@Scottthewolf - did you mean if I must buy a TOP load washer? I really don't want a front loader. There's always the odd sock or something I forgot to throw in - also I've heard they have odor issues. Please feel free to correct me if I'm mistaken on this.

I've had (and repaired) my own Whirlpool pair for over 20 years. Everything that could go wrong, has gone wrong in that timeframe. Absolutely everything. I even refinished the tub and cabinet. I would, however, like to get a washer that won't wake the dead when I use it (an issue with the Admiral/Roper) and would prefer adjustable water levels.

So - if Samsung is not recommended - then can you give me some model #s aside from the lowest priced basics?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The higher-priced models cost more because of electronic controls and government required energy savings and "lower water usage"

Most new front-loaders have electronic controls.

All Samsung parts are hard to get.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am soooo ambivalent about this. On one hand, I just can't see spending $400 or more for an Admiral or Roper that actually has less features than what I have now. We did that 10 years ago, and after one horrible day I gladly paid a restocking fee to return them.

On the other hand, I don't want to get something that I have to replace again in 4 years because I can't fix it. It's not the money - we are ok there. It's just that I don't want to feel like i made another mistake.

Dang. This is precisely why I keep fixing the Whirlpools. But I'm not sure if it's the dogs or something else - it's not agitating, but the shaft doesn't spin in my hands like it does when the dogs go out. I just don't think my heart is in this anymore.

Maybe I'll just replace the washer and take my chances. There's nothing wrong with the dryer. Who cares if they match?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Far as I'm aware, that Admiral unit is no longer produced. No more Whirlpool-made direct-drive units of any brand except maybe a Whirlpool and Maytag coin-op or commercial on-premise model. Availability now is limited to stock on-hand at any given source. HomeDepot.com still lists it for $399. Be aware also that this is a one-speed machine. The delicate cycle runs at high agitation speed, but agitation is intermittent (something like 10 seconds on, 45 seconds off) for the duration of the wash and rinse periods. Spin speed is only high. It also likely has a "crippled" rinse water level, fixed at approx 5" to 6" depth regardless of what is the selected water level on the control (which is only for the wash level). Parts listing for the model ATW4475XQ0 shows two water level switches ... one accessible via the console (wash level), the other hidden inside not accessible (rinse level).

Used Whirly direct-drive machines are plentiful on the used market ... CraigsList and local reseller shops. Some very good condition, some rode hard and put away wet. Kenmore, Whirlpool, Roper, Estate, Admiral, a few KitchenAids, and Maytags produced between 2006-ish and 2010-ish. Check units of consideration closely to confirm operational details. Newer specimens with reduced water levels typically advise of it via the lid instructions.

A used machine can be a good and reasonable deal, even if some repairs may be necessary. A friend was going to throw out a 1999 Kenmore 90 that they thought had bad bearings, asked if I wanted it. Was only a broken drive coupler. I completely disassembled the machine, replaced the inner basket which had some rust development around the perfs from sitting unused a couple years. Replaced the lid which had been blown open and damaged during transport. Also rust-treated the base pedestal, tub support, rear panel, and interior of the cabinet just for insurance so it'll be good for a long time. It turned out in great condition (other than the replaced lid being white due to almond NLA). Cost of machine = free. Cost of parts = $217. I kept the machine for 1.5 years waiting for an incident of need to arise. My parents took it last week when the timer on their washer broke.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, then go for the Whirlpool family of top load washers if you don't want a front load washer.

General Electric makes a horrible top load washer, they eliminated the transmission and replaced it with this mode shifter assembly and motor with an inverter, which has a high failure rate.

Frigidaire's top load washer is mediocore in repairs, but easy to work on, it's design dates back to the 1970s. They are designing a new washer as we speak. If the Frigidaire washer engineers are as crazy as the refrigerator engineers, it will be overengineered and hard to work on.

Don't fall for the Fisher & Paykel top load washer, it may be a decent washer, but hard to get parts for.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the info on some of the other American brands - most appreciated.

Why do servicers refuse to work on Samsungs? Just trying to understand if it's a philosophical thing ("Buy American") or something else. Is there something aside from the parts being hard to get that I need to know about? Samsung hasn't been in the laundry game for very long, and I'm inclined to believe that the parts will be more readily available in time.

I'm pushing the point a bit because the reviews on the Whirlpools are just awful (the Cabrios seem to have a lot of problems that surface quickly after warranty expiration), whereas the majority of consumers seem very pleased with their Korean machines. And when I said I would like to be able to fix my own washer, I don't really want to have to do it. Unlike you, appliance repair is not my career and there are oh-so-many other things I would rather do with my weekends!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why do servicers refuse to work on Samsungs? Just trying to understand if it's a philosophical thing ("Buy American") or something else.

Two Big Reasons:

1. They are buttheads with their tech info-- only their "authorized" slaves can have access to their tech information. Which you really need because...

2. Their parts ordering is clusterf*ck nightmare. They're famous for switching parts mid-stream in a model production so you often get the wrong part when you order. And their parts distribution system is an abortion that (almost) lived.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you like the Korean models ..

Check out he LG's

We use a pair of front-loaders

Parts are now more readily available..

and service information for most models is also available here on-line

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, I agree: LG would be a good choice. I also like LG because they make tech info available to all servicers at their tech assist website.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ahhh... I am most honored that after all these years Grand Master has commented in one of my threads!!! Thank you so much for explaining. I will not be purchasing the Samsungs and will be heading out this afternoon to take a look at alternatives.

There seems to be a contingent of consumers dissatisfied with HE machines in general, but my impression is that these folks did not read the manuals.

I had dismissed front loaders because of issues with odor, but now I'm reading that the new HE top loaders may have the same problem if the lid is not left open. So...Should I reconsider front loaders? Do they really clean better? Are they harder to fix than toploaders? Any other drawbacks?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We have had a front loader for over 10 years, family of five, washer used daily. Not a single odor problem at any time. Most odor problems in frontload washers are caused by one of two things: people using the wrong detergent (non-HE detergent) or using too much detergent. Most people don't realize that detergent residue makes great food for bacteria, molds, mildew's et cetera. When it comes to detergents, there is such a thing as too much of a good thing.

Have fun shopping!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

... Are they harder to fix than toploaders?

... because of energy savings and mechanical changes (direct drive Motor, no Transmission, etc)

There are more electronics ..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you are considering a front load washer, you need to leave the door open at the end of every cycle. The door gasket is a breeding ground for black mold which does smell.

Hot water and bleach need to be used periodically even if you just wash towels or rags once a week. Many of the complaints on front load washers come from customers trying to be "environmentally safe" by not using bleach or hot water.

Sears, Home Depot and Lowe's all sell AFFRESH washer cleaning tablets for front load washers to use periodically to clean out the washer. When using these cleaning tablets they need to be used on a wash cycle with NO clothes in the washer.

If I were you, I would stick with a top loading washer. You still have the likelyhood of the main outer tub seal and bearing going bad in a front load washer which is very expensive to repair and I do not reccommend this job for a do it yourselfer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thank you all for your feedback. I think we've settled on the LG toploader - WT5170HW and electric dryer - DLEX5170W. Searching for the best price... and still dithering on whether to purchase the extended warranty. Seems pricey to me (~$500 for 4 years), but I have no idea what LG parts cost. Could be a total waste of money, but on the other hand it could be a screamin' deal if something major goes wrong.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

... LG toploader - WT5170HW

... electric dryer - DLEX5170W.

... whether to purchase the extended warranty.

here's a site: http://www.ajmadison.com/

WT5170HW $ 1099 - 10% = $ 989 (ends today 7/22) (sale sometimes every few weeks)

DLEX5170W $ 999 - 10% off = $ 899 (ends today 7/22) (sale sometimes every few weeks)

maybe free (curbside) delivery (enter zip code)

$ 99 (in house) (pair ?)

Warranty: Squaretrade

30% OFF sale every few weeks

Washer OR Dryer (up to $999) :

warranty 3 yrs $ 99 - 30% = $69

warranty 5 yrs add $ 100 = $ 169

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry, I will still express my opinion on buying something made in Korea and the profits going OUT of the USA. That's why the USA is in this mess with our economy. People keep feeding the profits to other countries.

Good luck with your LG. Keep the Koreans working. Let those hourly employees at the Whirlpool washing machine plant in Clyde, Ohio get their hours cut or worse, let them get laid off.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@Scottthewolf - LG employs on all continents - including North America (LG Electronics Alabama employs ~900 workers).

I sense that you have a personal investment in this issue. I am familiar with Whirlpool's battle with Korean competitors, and I agree - up to a point. I am opposed to outsourcing and "work visa" hiring that directly impacts domestic employment. This, however, is a trade issue. The U.S. benefits from trade relations with other countries; in order to be able to export our products, we must also allow imports. Did you know that Whirlpool exports 12% of its products to other countries? That they have manufacturing plants in Mexico, China, Russia, India, and Poland? Whirlpool won duties on South Korean and Mexican refrigerators in the very same month last year that they shut down an Arkansas refrigerator plant and moved production to Mexico. So I am not sure that I feel much sympathy for Whirlpool, the outsourcer. And, I'm also not convinced - based on Whirlpool's track record - that buying the Cabrios made in Clyde, Ohio will in any way help those workers to keep their jobs. No matter how many washers are sold, Whirlpool will ultimately move manufacturing wherever it is cheapest and most expedient. It would not surprise me in the least if at some point the company moves production of its washers to Korea. How would that be for irony?

But this is a laundry repair forum... not a political forum. I sought purchase advice based solely on features and ease of repair. If the Cabrio had received better ratings from CR and consumers than its Korean counterparts, then that is what I would be buying. Bottom line: if Whirlpool wants to compete in a global economy, the company should spend less time and money lobbying the Feds and invest more of its resources in making a quiet, reliable product that Americans want to buy. JMO

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey Guys

If you want a workhorse TLW, Check out Speed Queen. A little pricey but really strong and very repairable.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I got your reliable TLW right here...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Also I forgot to mention it's made in WI, By cheese heads YA hey dere. They also are mainly US Parts except the switches and emerson motor

I worked on a few maytag E2lp & j2lps in my early maytag dealer service career

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No one wants to work that hard to get the wash done anymore. Also Its very hard to use facebook when you are using the wringer!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites